Need a Plumber? Call Now
Regal Plumbing & Rooter logo
Technician running a sewer camera through the toilet flange after pulling the toilet in Ontario, CA
Toilets

Toilet Keeps Clogging After Snaking? Check the Toilet

By Nick Moore
Owner and C-36 Licensed Plumbing Contractor, CA Lic. #1097482
November 17, 2026·4 min read·Ontario, CA

When a toilet keeps clogging even after it's been snaked, the problem may not be in the pipe at all. On a recent job in Ontario, the clog was a flat broken piece of what looked like a bidet seat, lodged inside the toilet itself, in the toilet's trap. Here's how we found it and what fixed it.

Why does my toilet keep clogging after it's been snaked?

Because something may be stuck in the toilet's own trap, deep at the bend where you can't see it. On the job below, snaking the toilet made it flush for a few rounds, but it backed up again as soon as it was tested with tissue paper.

That's exactly what the Ontario homeowners were dealing with. They had moved in about two weeks earlier, and the upstairs toilet had given them trouble since day one. They tried a hand auger, and the clog kept coming back. When we ran our own hand auger through it, the toilet flushed fine a few times, then backed up again as soon as we tested it with tissue paper.

How do you tell if the clog is in the toilet or the pipe?

Pull the toilet and look at both sides with a camera. After a few rounds with the auger, we pulled the toilet to check the closet bend and the line below it. There was no water sitting in the drain, and the camera showed the line was clear, which is what we'd expect in a newer home built around the late 2000s.

Then we fed the camera up into the toilet's trap from underneath, and there it was: a flat piece of what looked like a bidet seat, lodged in the very top of the trap at the deepest bend, completely out of sight from above. Our best guess is that the previous owners had a bidet seat on that toilet, it broke when they took it off, and a piece fell in.

Camera view looking up into a toilet's built-in trap, showing a flat white piece wedged at the deepest bend

The line itself was fine. The problem was in the toilet the whole time.

Can you get an object out of a toilet trap, or do you have to replace the toilet?

Sometimes you can work it out, but a flat object is very hard to work loose. We spent about 30 minutes trying to dislodge the piece. Because it was flat, there was nothing to get underneath, and it sat deep in the trap where it couldn't be seen.

Toilet pulled off the floor with the drain open and a camera reel ready in a bathroom in Ontario, CA

At that point we gave the homeowners two options: keep working at it, with a good chance of cracking the toilet in the process, or replace the toilet. They didn't like that toilet anyway, so we installed a brand new American Standard, a brand we recommend for its simplicity and reliability, with a new wax ring and hardware. The whole job, diagnosis and the new toilet included, took about four hours.

For this kind of repair, the range runs from about $350 to $1,300 and up, depending on what the object is and where it's stuck. A repeat clog like this won't fix itself, so we always lay out a short-term option and a permanent fix we can warranty.

What should you do if something falls into the toilet?

Don't flush. If you can't reach it and pull it out, call a plumber before it moves into the drain. Things like this are common, especially in homes with kids, who love dropping toys in and watching them disappear.

For an ordinary clog, try a plunger first. If plunging doesn't clear it, that's the time to call.

Why do flat objects in the drain get expensive?

Because once a flat, wide object leaves the toilet, it can catch at a turn in the pipe. If a snake can't break it up, the options are cutting out the piece of pipe that's holding it, or trying to push it further down the line, which we don't recommend. That's why the time to call is while the item is still in the toilet, before it enters the plumbing system, where things can get expensive fast.

If your toilet in Ontario keeps clogging, see our Ontario drain cleaning page or our Ontario plumbing page. To see what a camera inspection shows, read our post on annual sewer camera inspections. Call (909) 600-4561.

Frequently Asked Questions

Need Help With Your Plumbing?

Regal Plumbing & Rooter serves Ontario, Rancho Cucamonga, Fontana, Pomona, Corona, Upland, West Covina, Chino and surrounding communities. Call us 24/7.

Call Now: (909) 600-4561

Have a Plumbing Question?

Call us any time. We are happy to help with advice or service.

(909) 600-4561Call Now